Thursday, October 23, 2008

  • If You Got Knocked Up, Would You Marry the Babydaddy?

    marigold by miss marigold 

    If you got knocked up, would you marry the babydaddy?

    It seems like the media's giving a lot of attention to women (and sometimes, girls) who bear children out of wedlock - Bristol Palin and Jamie-Lynn Spears are more or less the poster children for the term "knocked up" - and just yesterday, I read some gossip story about how Jennifer Aniston proposed to John Mayer after finding out that she's pregnant with his baby.

    Pregnancies happen every day, and even though most Christians preach against premarital sex, Christian girls get pregnant all the time, as it's also common for Christian guys to impregnate girls. What I'm wondering is if it's really advisable to get married for the sake of the unborn child, though. Bristol Palin and Jamie-Lynn are supposedly engaged to their babydaddies. Pete Wentz and Ashlee Simpson got married right when Simpson got pregnant. I even know a guy who left our junior year at college as an eligible stud, and returned right after summer married to his ex-girlfriend/the mother of his child.

    Were I to get pregnant out of wedlock, I'm not sure that I'd marry the father - well, unless we'd been dating seriously for a few years and I knew I wanted to marry him anyway. Maybe I'd be tempted to marry him for the added financial support. Maybe I'd want to marry him so our child could have the two healthy parents it deserves. Maybe I'd marry him society wouldn't look down on me as a single mother.

    But what good would it do the child if the father and I REALLY weren't compatible as a married couple? And honestly, in terms of social appearances alone, it doesn't look that great either if you get married really quickly because you got pregnant.

    Is it wise for couples who got pregnant out of wedlock to get married for the child's sake? Does your faith take a side either way?

Comments (76)

  • hubbaduh@xanga

    Just b/c a girl/woman gets pregnant, DOES NOT mean that she should marry the father.  If that's the ONLY reason someone gets married, to me, they're getting married for all the wrong reasons.

  • aznspartan94@xanga

    How many of those teenagers just slap the title of "Christian" onto their reputation without giving it a thought? For that matter, how many of us have a bunch of titles that we take just for the heck of it?

  • FallenReign@xanga

    I don't really intend on getting pregnant or anything until I get married, but if I was put in that situation and I honestly thought that me and him were compatible and that I would want to marry him anyways, I would, but I wouldn't marry a totally incompatible person for the child; they would think that kind of relationship is healthy and normal, when it really isn't. 

  • meadowroom@xanga

    While it seems to be smart to get married for the child's sake, it honestly doesn't make mush sense.  It is what my parents did though (I came a bit earlier than expected...born 5 months after the wedding), but my parents had been dating for nearly four years by that point.  When you have been with the person for several years that, than it makes a lot more sense than if you go off and have a one night stand and get married to the guy.  That may be a little extreme, but still, if you have not talked with the guy about a serious lifelong relationship and you get pregnant.....you should still consider the lifelong relationship part very seriously.  In some cases, it may be better for the child to have a single parent than two parents who cannot get along at all and end up divorcing and causing distress to the young child.

  • rantingwraven@xanga

    Okay, I like mayer's music but Dude or dudette you are reading the wrong kind of material that's in the "Kingdom" I know,


    Who cares, Yes I do care and pray for my enemys but these people have never confessed following the big J that I know of. Are you lost ???????  

  • leadworshipper82

    this I really think should be a shift in perspective...


    the girl really shouldn't cuz considering the guy was dumb enough not to play it smart and get a girl pregnant clearly shows a lack of responsibility on his end and in turn made the girl a victim... granted it is mutual responsibility... but really though... if the dood is dumb enough to not play it smart... would he be a good choice for life?


    that is, unless he mans up and takes some serious responsibility and makes up for his mistakes and grow some cahonies and take care of the kid...


    more or less... I'm gonna have to say no she should not marry him for the same reason she got knocked up in the first place, the dood is a scuz unless he grows some and mans up...


    now if it was a mistake and the guy is a credible guy... she can...


    but if the guy is a fool, then I personally wouldn't marry a boy like that... even if he can shave...

  • lilwetduckie@momaroo

    I believe you should do what you feel right! If you love the guy and can't imagine life without him, then do it -- I wouldn't say JUMP into marriage right away, but think about it. My mom got pregnant at the age of 17 and had me at 18. My mom got pregnant with her then boyfriend. He basically gave some excuse as to why he couldn't let his parents know that she was pregnant with his child, so she left him. She did not see a point in staying with someone who didn't even want to claim the child. She didn't marry someone just to have a father-figure, she ended up marrying someone who loved her, and me as his own daughter. In my eyes, he is my dad, I don't need bloodwork to tell me otherwise. My "biological" father doesn't really take part in my life, he calls me every once in a while and Myspaces me -- but that is it. I call him by his first name and that is how it will always be. I am glad my mom didn't marry the baby's daddy in my case.


    You should always marry when you feel it is right, never rush into it. Marry someone you know will be good to you and your child, not just 'cause he has the same blood type as the child.


    I am sorry if this comment is all over the place, I feel like I have jumped around. I just have so much to say on this subject.

  • brwnidgrljenn@xanga

    Being as I know this scenario first hand (single mom @ 20), I was not opposed to getting married when I found out I was pregnant.  My boyfriend, however, did not want that to be the only reason we got married.  For us, we were young, stupid and basically fell into a relationship we weren't ready for.  Looking back (my son is 12), it actually was the right decision for us.  Long term, we were not compatible.  I don't say that this is the right decision for every couple...sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't.  I've seen it both ways - I know one couple that married because she was pregnant and they've been happily married for almost 10 years.  Another couple I know that got married because she was pregnant, their marriage only lasted five years.  Of course, the ideal is a child to be born into a two parent household.  The reality in this day & age is that even if you are married years before you have a child does not guarantee that your child will not have to endure a single parent household.  I would have to say that it would depend on the couple, their maturity in the situation and whether there is anything else to substantiate a marriage.  Getting married for the sole reason of a pregnancy, in my opinion, is not enough.  There has to be more to make that marriage a good solid relationship.


    Just because you are Christian doesn't mean you don't stray from what you know is right.  That would be me.  Having my son helped me return to my Christian life and to re-dedicate my life to God. 

  • Tokimon@xanga

    um, depends.. most likely yea~  but if it's not the right guy.. then geez.. just no >.<;;

  • too_pretty_to_die@xanga

    how is it sensible to marry someone just because of a child?  i grew up in a single-parent household and absolutely loved it.

  • LordofRogues@xanga

    Two wrongs don't make a right.

    A bad relationship interest shouldn't be followed by a miserable marriage.

    Me personally? Probably. If it would be a good marriage. Then again, I'm married, and had I knocked her up I would have gladly married her anyway: to me, sex=marriage, it's how it was meant to be.

  • naphtali_deer@xanga

    First off, I'm having trouble with the title of this post: referring to pregnancy as being "knocked up." What are we saying about God's ordained way to create life when we use such a phrase? Please let's not resort to the world's ways of talking about the miracle of new life growing inside a mother's womb.

    If your only reason for marrying is to look good to others, that's not a good reason, and I would venture to say, probably a very poor reason. There must be a sense you are in God's will. Sometimes by marrying, I believe people think, "Oh, I blew it, but now I'll make things right by marrying," but that's not a good reason for marrying. And I also don't think there's one set answer we can give such a couple about whether they should marry or not. But we can trust that for those who are in Christ, God can redeem our sins and mistakes and bring much blessing in spite of ourselves. This is what happened in my life regarding an unplanned pregnancy.

    When I was in high school, I wasn't a Christian and I became pregnant. (And it does take two to tango, @leadworshipper82. There's equal responsibility there.)

    By the grace of God (even though I as I said, I did not know Him yet) and through the support and encouragement of family and friends, I gave birth to a wonderful daughter. I did occasionally think I wanted to marry her father, but he and I both decided we would not marry at that time since we were young and had school, etc. ahead of us. We thought perhaps we would marry after college, but in the meantime, our relationship ended.

    Years later when I was in graduate school (another story there about how God got me there--I was not yet a believer then either), I met the man I would soon marry. He was a Christian but I wasn't, but some time after meeting him I became a believer.

    Now here's the story behind our engagement. We did both acknowledge we liked each other and were spending lots of time together. One night he had been looking at a picture of my daughter and me I had up on the wall of my apartment and became impressed that he wasn't just supposed to marry me but to be my daughter's father as well. (And he hadn't even met my daughter at that point since she was living with my family in another city!) Anyhow, that was the night he asked me to marry him, 26 years ago this November. God provided the perfect husband for me in His perfect time.

    Instead of asking this hypothetical marriage question, I think a better question any unmarried Christian men and women out there should be asking is: "What steps can I take to keep myself pure and undefiled until the day I am married?" And then to be praying that you might be fully satisfied in Christ (for He alone is truly the One who satisfied) and for His strength to help you remain chaste so long as you are not married.

  • E_muse@xanga

    Your considerations have made the question moot. Anyone smart enuf to know that two and two make four ought to be disciplined enuf to reject intercourse. It's like the drunk driver that kills someone in an accident and claims innocence because he was drunk and not responsible. When he made the decision to drink he was (hopefully) not brain impaired. We committ acts in full knowledge of consequences. Women have allowed themselves to be hoodwinked into pregnamncy for time immemorial. When you dance you have to pay the fiddler Concequences of premarital sex have eternal implications.

  • SeitekiChibiNeko@xanga

    if i got knocked up i would be furious, and i definitely wouldn't marry the guy...more like give him a black eye! LOL there wouldn't be a point in getting married, 'cuz i'd be responsible and give the kid up for adoption to someone who is desperate for a child and financially ready for kids. 3 people in my close family were adopted and it worked out well! :)

  • sarahflorida1085@xanga

    Christianity definately encourages the mother and father to marry to "fix" their problem, i guess its a matter when they are financially stable enough as well as mature enough to stay together, as well committed...otherwise it will be a complete disaster and i think shouldn't happen

  • chinaman

    Okey , call me a prude right now but this discussion would not take place if we follow the " old ' and "traditional" christian belief of no sex outside marriage . I mean , we are all discussing  this in terms of christian values but the point is if we really call ourselves christians then sex should not be happening among  people not married to each other , right ?   

  • KKNABrowning@xanga

    My first pregnancy, the babydady was a military man and I did love him but I didn't want that life. I didn't want to move my kids everywhere and didn't want to feel like I was the supportive wife that was seen and not heard. I chose to go at it alone. He threatened me and told me he would take my baby. I ran and hid for a while till the baby was 4 years old. He came back with 3 other kids. I still am not impressed with him but he was my first love and the bio dad of my baby. He still doesn't have contact with us and thats fine with me. My daughter asked this year if she could send him a birthday card (his bady is Oct 28) I said yes but I am still afraid of him rejecting her but someday they will have to work things out. I am very glad I didn't marry him, my family looked down on me as the single tattooed and peirced rebelian. I was ok with that but I swore I would wait till I was ready to be married to have baby number two. I met Mr Right a couple of years ago but didn't fall for himtill about a year and a half ago. I wasn't thinking of babies or marriage when I spent the weekend but 6 weeks later I was ready to run again. he didn't let me he told me he would be there and would help in anyway. He was a great guy and now he is a great dad. I married him August of last year but I was 5 months pregnant. I am a proud wife and mother. i hope everyone has the chance to fall in love with the person who "knocked them up" I certinly have.

  • momma2babies34

    while some can last, but i totally never seen any successful marriage after the pregnancy/child's birth. i am one of them. when we became pregnant, i was all for being on my own with his help if he was interested.


    until one situation came up i felt hopeless and lost, when he demanded we got married and gave in. our marriage was NOT great. we ended up totally seperated parents that my children never got good impression of parenting.


    eventually we got divorced. my best friend got married when she discovered having her lover's baby, but now six years later is filing divorce. her mother was  the same way.


    a lot of people i knew are that way.


    but like you said, unless they been dating for a long time and knew they wanted to be married to each other, it is likely to last.


    i am totally against people marrying for the sake of their child. they need to think in a long run. which is better, being a single mother and do well on raising the child or being married and be horrible at each other and giving children wrong example of marriage?

  • gefforyt@xanga

    @leadworshipper82 - You have to be kidding. The girl is a victim because she got pregnant and it is all the boys fault?. Get a grip. Does the the girl not know how to say "get a rubber or you get nothing"? Does a girl now know how to get on the pill? It's called mutual responsibility. it is never one persons fault because some one ended up pregnant. 

  • leadworshipper82
  • gefforyt@xanga

    @leadworshipper82 - actually you said the girl is a victim because she got pregnant. Is she a victim or not?

  • leadworshipper82

    @gefforyt@xanga - well... in general and statistically... most boys tend to force themselves upon a girl... either through manipulative means or by coercive force... but there IS a mutuality to it... then run off once the girl gets pregnant...


    isn't that victimization in essence?

  • redshad@xanga

    I see the whole problem here being our attitudes toward dating. Temptation is strong in the young, who lack the experience to fight it efficaciously. I think Christian youths should return to a practice of earlier times, where young men and young women did not come together without a chaperon, and went out in groups rather than alone. The old ways were not 100% effective, but nevertheless better than today.

  • anonymous

    there are several thoughts i have to go through before answering this question.
    1. i wouldn't get pregnant, i use birth control.
    2. if i would get pregnant, i have 12 weeks to have a legal abortion. that's 3 months, anyone would notice by then.
    3. i would never marry anyone i don't love.

    my ex told me he'd marry his gf because she's pregnant with his child. he's 27, she's 19. he wanted to break up with her a month prior to her getting pregnant, he even cheated on her. (she cheated as well, but months before.) but she convinced him to stay. anyone surprised that she get pregnant right away?

    i would never do this to a child. i feel like a divorce is way worse for a child than growing up with parents that aren't together, but happy and there for the kid. it's pathetic to think a child will fix a relationship.

  • mamma_sez

    I married my babies father

    a.  We are NOT that compatible as a couple- but over the years we have grown together and found mutual ground, so far our marriage has last despite a tumultuous start as a testimony to God's grace, not to our own abilities.

    b.  My babies father, wanted to be a father, and wanted to marry me.  It was I who was not so sure. 

    c.  I could not bear the idea of my child growing up without a dad who wanted to be there.  So even though at the time I didn't consider his dad the perfect mate to spend the rest of my life with, I sucked it up and made the decision for my child.  For us it has payed off.  Probably similar to the way some arranged marriages work.

    d.  I would not recommend it to everybody, but nor would I discourage it.  We are able to do all things, through Christ who strengthens us.  He is well able to redeem the not so perfect marriage.

    e. It has worked well for us- and 2 other couples I know that it happened too around the same time.  Their/our marriages are a testimony ONLY to God's work in our lives not anything special on our parts.

    x

  • Choose Identity

  • Give eProps (?)