Weblog

Wednesday, January 07, 2009

  • Reading lists - help me out.

    I post a lot of reading lists.  Only in the last couple of months, I have posted a Christian discipleship reading list, a Eugene Peterson reading list and a nonviolence reading list.

    Now, I would like your input.  It's your turn.

    Please leave a comment on this post recommending a book you don't think I've read.  Let me know whether this was an important book to you, or whether it's a book you think I specifically need to read.  Give a brief argument why that book, and not some other, should be at the top of my reading list.  Feel free to list more than one, but don't feel compelled to. 

    Thanks in advance.

    <edit> I don't really ask for recs, but to get a wider range of answers, I wouldn't mind seeing this rec'd. </edit>

    -Nicholas Stanton Roark

Monday, January 05, 2009

  • Accountability and Israel - a word for a church

    The Israeli enemy in its aggression has written its next chapter in the world which will have no place for them. They shelled everyone in Gaza. They shelled children and hospitals and mosques and in doing so, they gave us legitimacy to strike them in the same way.

    - Mouhmad Zahar, Hamas leader

    Israel, in response to these claims, alleges that its targets were military, housing rocket launchers or militants.  But Israel has offered no evidence of these defenses, and is allowing no journalists in the area, and is allowing no international military, paramilitary or interpol presence in the warzone.  So there is no accountability for either side.

    Meanwhile, Hamas foolishly continues to pepper the nearest Israeli city with rockets, making international calls for an Israeli-led ceasefire difficult to support. 

    What does the church say to this situation?  Nothing substantially new, I think.  The church would call for a ceasefire from both sides, and I think has to hold both sides accountable for the levels this has escalated to.  What is important now, though, is not blame, not even peace, but aid for those civilians trapped in the warzone, where water is scarce, bodies of slain militants lay strewn about the streets, and one in five Palestinian dead are civilian.

    In appealing to Israel, the church should speak to our commonality, calling Israel to stand on the moral high ground it has consistently claimed for itself.  The church should speak unequivocally and publicly to Israel, urging for, if nothing else, an honest declaration of intent.  If Israel will not cease the military campaign, it must at the very least allow journalists and humanitarian relief workers into the area.  Their refusal to do so strikes the same chords with the world as Hamas' continual firing of rockets into Israeli residential areas. 

    In all of this, I believe God has a word for the church as well.  I would imagine that if the church were unified and true enough to Christ's way, it would have the moral authority to simply walk into the area (or it would already be in the area) to minister to those in need.  Certainly, we could work in ways unknown to the nations.  Even if denied access at gunpoint to the warzone, the church could by its prophetic presence make a spectacle of the Israeli military, if it would truly prefer to point their guns at Christians rather than to see their enemies' wives and children cared for.

    In the end, the point is made in the spiteful quote above as Jesus himself made it.  Don't you know that he who takes the sword shall die by the sword?  All these cycles of violence, someone has to stand outside it all and break the cycles of retribution.

    -NDSR
  • Israel and Hamas

    You know, it's very difficult to take any international call for Israel to cease hostilities seriously when rockets continue to fire from the Gaza strip into residential Israel. 

    On the other hand, when the U.S. Government comes out and says that we don't want an end to the fighting because we don't like the status quo, that is difficult to support.

  • By preaching the Gospel message, by its sacraments, and by the charity of its members, the Church proclaims and shelters the gift of the Kingdom of God in the heart of human history.

    - Gustavo Gutierrez, Theology of Liberation

Sunday, January 04, 2009

  • The golden rule is wrong

    Or, to be more accurate, we get it wrong.  We got this idea that Jesus' most central teaching was to love God with all your heart, mind, soul and strength, and to love your neighbor as yourself.  That wasn't Jesus' central teaching, that was his summary (or the most important bit) of the Jewish law. 

    Jesus' golden rule was this: "I give you a new commandment: love one another. Just as I have loved you, you must also love one another. By this all people will know that you are My disciples, if you have love for one another."

    This goes beyond loving your neighbor as yourself.  Loving your neighbor as yourself is something common to just about every religion (or not doing to your neighbor as you would not have them to do you, etc.).  It is also the kind of natural-law teaching you can build a social ethic from.  You could build law on that principle, because everyone knows what they would not want done to them.

    There is nothing particularly Christian about it.

    On this basis, Augustine justified disobeying Jesus' teachings against nonviolence.  He said, "It's true we can't use violence to defend ourselves.  BUT we have to follow the golden rule, which means we have to use violence to defend our neighbors, whom we love as ourselves."

    On the other hand, not everyone can follow the commandment to love one another as Jesus has loved us.  Only one who has experienced the transforming love of Christ can know that.  What is more, no secular social ethic could proceed from the commandment.  You cannot justify violence in defense of another on the basis of loving as Jesus loved, for Jesus loved nonviolently. 

    What is more, this love says something unique about who Jesus is and what the Kingdom means.  To love your neighbor as yourself is common-sense.  That's how the human race will survive.  But to love as Jesus loved... by this the world will know that we are Jesus' disciples. 

    -NDSR

sirnickdon

  • Visit sirnickdon's Revelife Site
    • Name: Nick-Don
    • Gender: Male
    • Member Since: 8/2/2008

Weblog Archives

Don't worry - your calendar is here… to see it in action just click "Save" above and refresh the page.